1.这一主题是否与杂志相关并适用？
2.这一议题是否具有重大意义和广泛的国际兴趣？
3.标题和摘要对文章的表述是否有意义和准确？
4.结论新颖吗？
5.工作目标是否明确？
6.数据质量是否足够，误差范围是否量化？
7.方法和分析是否适当、充分解释且无错误？
8.结论是否得到数据和分析的充分支持？
9.这篇论文组织得好吗？
10.这篇论文是用简明明了的英语写的吗？
11.这些图和表格质量好吗？它们都是必要的吗？
12.参考资料是否相关和最新？

1.Is this topic relevant and suitable for the journal Advances in Polar Science?
2.Is the topic significant and of broad international interest?
3.Do the title and abstract give a meaningful and accurate representation of the article?
4.Are the conclusions novel?
5.Are the objectives of the work clearly outlined?
6.Are the data of sufficient quality, and are error bounds quantified?
7.Are the methods and analyses appropriate, adequately explained and free from error?
8.Are the conclusions adequately supported by the data and analysis?
9.Is this paper properly organized?
10.Is this paper written using clear and concise English-language?
11.Are the figures and tables of good quality and are they all necessary?
12.Is the referencing relevant and up to date?