译：Asp.Net Identity与Owin，到底谁是谁？

2023-07-24 13:56:40

送给正在学习Asp.Net Identity的你 ：-）

原文出自 trailmax 的博客AspNet Identity and Owin. Who is who.

Recently I have found an excellent question on *. The OP asks why does claim added to Idenetity after calling AuthenticationManager.SignIn still persist to the cookie.

最近我在*发现一个非常好的（妙啊）问题，OP提出的问题是，在调用AuthenticationManager.SignIn之后再向Identity添加Claim ，这些后添加的Claim仍然被保存在了Cookies里。

The sample code was like this:

代码是这样的

ClaimsIdentity identity = UserManager.CreateIdentity(user, DefaultAuthenticationTypes.ApplicationCookie );

var claim1 = new Claim(ClaimTypes.Country, "Arctica");

identity.AddClaim(claim1);

AuthenticationManager.SignIn(new AuthenticationProperties { IsPersistent = true }, identity );

var claim2 = new Claim(ClaimTypes.Country, "Antartica");

identity.AddClaim(claim2);

Yeah, why does claim2 is available after cookie is already set.

噢耶，为什么在已经设置cookie之后claim2仍然是有效的呢？

After much digging I have discovered that AspNet Identity framework does not set the cookie. OWIN does. And OWIN is part of Katana Project which has open source code. Having the source code available is always nice – you can find out yourself why things work or don’t work the way you expect.

在我深度挖掘之后，我发现 AspNet Identity framework 并没有真的去设置cookie，是Owin做的。Owin是开源项目Katana的一部分（译者注：katana微软对于Owin的实现，Owin的实现还有其它的）。能看源代码总是一件很棒的事，因为你能自己去寻找为什么事情是这样的或者为什么结果和预期的不一致的答案。

In this case I have spent a few minutes navigating Katana project and how AuthenticationManager works. Turned out that SingIn method does not set a cookie. It saves Identity objects into memory until time comes to set response cookies. And then claims are converted to a cookie and everything magically works ：-)

在这件事里，我花了几分钟时间找到Katana的源码寻找AuthenticationManager的工作原理。原来SignIng方法并没有设置Cookie。直到设置相应cookie之前，它只是将Identity对象放在了内存里。然后 claims被转换成cookie，并且，神奇的事情发生了：-D（应该是这么翻译吧...）

译者注:下面是SignIn的源码，源码地址

public void SignIn(AuthenticationProperties properties, params ClaimsIdentity[] identities)

{

    AuthenticationResponseRevoke priorRevoke = AuthenticationResponseRevoke;

    if (priorRevoke != null)

    {

        // Scan the sign-outs's and remove any with a matching auth type.

        string[] filteredSignOuts = priorRevoke.AuthenticationTypes

            .Where(authType => !identities.Any(identity => identity.AuthenticationType.Equals(authType, StringComparison.Ordinal)))

            .ToArray();

        if (filteredSignOuts.Length < priorRevoke.AuthenticationTypes.Length)

        {

            if (filteredSignOuts.Length == 0)

            {

                AuthenticationResponseRevoke = null;

            }

            else

            {

                AuthenticationResponseRevoke = new AuthenticationResponseRevoke(filteredSignOuts);

            }

        }

    }

    AuthenticationResponseGrant priorGrant = AuthenticationResponseGrant;

    if (priorGrant == null)

    {

        AuthenticationResponseGrant = new AuthenticationResponseGrant(new ClaimsPrincipal(identities), properties);

    }

    else

    {

        ClaimsIdentity[] mergedIdentities = priorGrant.Principal.Identities.Concat(identities).ToArray();

        if (properties != null && !object.ReferenceEquals(properties.Dictionary, priorGrant.Properties.Dictionary))

        {

            // Update prior properties

            foreach (var propertiesPair in properties.Dictionary)

            {

                priorGrant.Properties.Dictionary[propertiesPair.Key] = propertiesPair.Value;

            }

        }

        AuthenticationResponseGrant = new AuthenticationResponseGrant(new ClaimsPrincipal(mergedIdentities), priorGrant.Properties);

    }

}

This sparked another question. At the moment Identity does not have open source, but what is the role of OWIN in Identity and how Claims work here?

这引发了另一个问题，此时 Identity还没有开源，但是Identity中OWIN的Role是什么，并且，Claims是如何工作（译者注：发挥作用）的？

Turns out that Identity framework deals only with user persistence, password hashing, validating if the password is correct, sending out email tokens for password reset, etc. But Identity does not actually authenticate users or create cookies. Cookies are handled by OWIN.

原来Identity framework做的事只有用户持久化存储、密码Hash、验证密码是否是正确的、为重置密码发送带有Token的电子邮件等等。但是identity 没有真正的认证用户或者创建Cookie。Owin在处理Cookie。

Take a look on this code for signing in:

我们来看一下SignIng的代码：

public async Task SignInAsync(Microsoft.Owin.Security.IAuthenticationManager authenticationManager, ApplicationUser applicationUser, bool isPersistent)

{

    authenticationManager.SignOut(DefaultAuthenticationTypes.ApplicationCookie);

    ClaimsIdentity identity = await UserManager.CreateIdentityAsync(applicationUser, DefaultAuthenticationTypes.ApplicationCookie);

    authenticationManager.SignIn(new Microsoft.Owin.Security.AuthenticationProperties() { IsPersistent = isPersistent }, identity);

}

Identity only creates ClaimsIdentity which you can study on ReferenceSource site. And ClaimsIdentity is part of .Net framework, not some nuget-package from the interwebz. Then this claimsIdentity is passed to OWIN AuthenticationManager where a callback is set to assign cookies on when time comes to write headers on the response.

Identity只是创建了ClaimsIdentity，你可以在ReferenceSource （译者注：查看.Net源码的地方，微软官办，没保存的同学快快收藏吧！）上学习他的代码。而且ClaimsIdentity是.Net Freamwork的一部分，不是从互联网上下载的Nuget包（实在不懂interwebz是什么意思 Orz）。然后claimsIdentity被传给了OWIN AuthenticationManager，（断句）OWIN AuthenticationManager是设置在派送Cookie（assign cookies）上的一个Callcack回调，（断句）这个assign cookies是放在一个什么东西上，当到了向Response写Header的时候就搞这个东西（这句话太难翻译了，你一定要看看原话，我不保证这句话翻译正确 （：逃）

So far, so good, we have 3 parts here: Identity framework creating a ClaimsIdentity, OWIN creating a cookie from this ClaimsIdentity. And .Net framework which holds the class for ClaimsIdentity.

目前看来还不错。我们知道了这里有3个部分：

  • Identity framework 创建了一个ClaimsIdentity，
  • Owin为ClaimsIdentity创建了cookie
  • 持有 ClaimsIdentity的class的是.Net framework

When in your classes you access ClaimsPrincipal.Current, you only use .Net framework, no other libraries are used. And this is very handy!

当你在你的代码中访问ClaimsPrincipal.Current时，你只用的了.Net framework，没有其它库（library）被用到，这是非常方便的。

Default Claims

Identity framework does a nice thing for you. By default it adds a number of claims to a principal when user is logged in. Here is the list:

Identity framework帮你做了很多有用的事。默认情况下，在用户登录的时候，她会添加一些claims到principal（译者注：看一下Mvc中的HttpContext.User的类型，就是IPrincipal）。接下来是列表：

You can find the list of framework claim types on .Net Reference site. However, this list is not complete. You can make up your own claim types as you are pleased – this is just a string.

你能够在.Net Reference网站上找到claim type的列表。然而，这个列表并不完整。如果你喜欢，你完全可以制造你自己的claim type，因为它只是一个字符串而已。

If you want to add your own claim types, I recommend to use your own notation for the claim types. Something like “MyAppplication:GroupId” and keep all the claim types in one class as constants:

如果你想添加你自己的claim type ，我建议你在claim type上加上你自己独特的标记。比如：“MyAppplication:GroupId”，然后将它们作为 constants存在某个类里面。

public class MyApplicationClaimTypes

{

    public string const GroupId = "MyAppplication:GroupId";

    public string const PersonId = "MyAppplication:PersonId";

    // other claim types

}

This way you can always find where the claims are used and will not * with the framework claim types. Unless the claim you use matches framework claim types exactly, like ClaimTypes.Email.

这种方式让你能够找到哪里引用了这些claims，并且不会和framework中的claim type发生冲突。除非你使用的claim type的framework中的claim type精确匹配，例如：ClaimTypes.Email。

Adding default claims 添加默认的claims

I always add user’s email to the list of claims. I do that on user sign-in, same way the first code snippet adds claim1 and claim2:

我总是使用和第一个添加claim1和claim2相同的方式在用户登录时将用户的email添加到claims列表里。

public async Task SignInAsync(IAuthenticationManager authenticationManager, ApplicationUser applicationUser, bool isPersistent)

{

    authenticationManager.SignOut(

        DefaultAuthenticationTypes.ExternalCookie,

        DefaultAuthenticationTypes.ApplicationCookie);

    var identity = await this.CreateIdentityAsync(applicationUser, DefaultAuthenticationTypes.ApplicationCookie);

    // using default claim type from the framework

    identity.AddClaim(new Claim(ClaimTypes.Email, applicationUser.Email));

    authenticationManager.SignIn(new AuthenticationProperties() { IsPersistent = isPersistent }, identity);

}

You can add your default claims to all users here as well. But there is IClaimsIdentityFactory class that is assigned in UserManager. There is only one method there:

你可可以向所有用户添加默认的claims。但是在UserManager中有一个IClaimsIdentityFactory的类，它只定义了一个方法。

public interface IClaimsIdentityFactory<TUser, TKey> where TUser : class, IUser<TKey> where TKey : IEquatable<TKey>

{

    /// <summary>

    /// Create a ClaimsIdentity from an user using a UserManager

    /// </summary>

    Task<ClaimsIdentity> CreateAsync(UserManager<TUser, TKey> manager, TUser user, string authenticationType);

}

Default AspNet Identity implementation creates ClaimsIdentity, adds the default claims described above, adds claims stored in the database for the user: IdentityUserClaims. You can override this implementation and slip-in your own logic/claims:

默认的Asp.Net Identity实现创建ClaimsIdentity，添加之前提到的默认claims，添加存储在satabase中的属于这个用户的claims：IdentityUserClaims。你可以重写这个实现类，然后放进你自己的 logic/claims.

public class MyClaimsIdentityFactory : ClaimsIdentityFactory<ApplicationUser, string>

{

public override async Task CreateAsync(UserManager<ApplicationUser, string> userManager, ApplicationUser user, string authenticationType)

{

var claimsIdentity = await base.CreateAsync(userManager, user, authenticationType);

        claimsIdentity.AddClaim(new Claim("MyApplication:GroupId", "42"));

        return claimsIdentity;

    }

}

and assign it in UserManager:

将它赋值给UserManager：

public UserManager(MyDbContext dbContext)

    : base(new UserStore<ApplicationUser>(dbContext))

{

    // other configurations

    // Alternatively you can have DI container to provide this class for better application flexebility

    this.ClaimsIdentityFactory = new MyClaimsIdentityFactory();

}

正文结束

补充一些译者的话

如果你注意到文中提到登陆的代码authenticationManager.SignIn(new AuthenticationProperties() { IsPersistent = isPersistent }, identity);

在新的Mvc项目中勾选个人身份认证时所生成的基本代码已经变成了 var result = await SignInManager.PasswordSignInAsync(model.Email, model.Password, model.RememberMe, shouldLockout: false); ，我试过使用文中的方法，是可以正常登陆的。

因为最终SignInManager的PasswordSignInAsync方法几经辗转也调用了IAuthenticationManager实例的Sign方法完成登陆。

上一篇：C++ 线程学习


下一篇：java线程学习